In one of the cases, the Company has not done consolidation of financial statements for the year ending 31.03.2023. The statutory auditor has resigned after the audit. Can the new statutory auditor sign the consolidated financial statements of that year?

BY: K.V.Balasubramanyam

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

How to reverse GST on ITC of fixed assets used over years and now discarded

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Agriculture Income 2 lacs Short term Capital Gain 2 Lacs Interest income 90000- If the asessee has died whether Legal heirs are supposed to file return If legal heir certificate is not available How to file Return

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether Dry cleaning services would be covered under section 44AD / 44ADA. Would the same difference if it is under franchise agreement of particular Brand.

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

An oldman has died His income from Share trading during 2023-24 FY is around Rs 2lac Whether his heirs are required to file ITR as his Taxable income is below 3Lacs

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

SERVICE PENSION OF RETIRED ARMY OFFICER EXEMPED UNDER SECTION 10? ( IT IS NOT DISABILITY PENSION BUT SERVICE PENSION GRANTED TO ARMY PERSONNEL AFTER NORMAL RETIREMENT)

BY: CA Shrawan Suthar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether cost of improvement u/s.55 includes furniture cost for the purpose of computation of capital gain

BY: CA ATUL TOSHNIWAL

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

What would be the turnover amount in case of intra-day share trading and in case of Future and Option trading

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Deductor furnished all the payments and TDs on contracts under Husband PAN instead of part being dedcuted on Spouse income. Even payment is also made in her bank account. As deductor is showing inability in revision of TDS return and feedback in AIS statement can also be not confirmed, if submitted. In this circumstances, can we directly show under TDS column in ITR and claim it in Spouse ITR?

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Assets purchased in AY 2014-15 and ITR filed at cost without taking valuation difference. Even ITD not raised any objection thereof. on sale of the same, what would be the cost of acquisition, actual price or valuation price as per the registered deed. Both value is mentioned in the deed.

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

One of the client has received amount of Rs.25,27,000 during FY 2023-24 towards compensation for Delay in Giving Possession of Flats to Land Owner towards his share of Flats as per Development Agreement. Developer has deducted TDS under sectoin 194I(b) from the said payment. Delay payment was for the period from FY 2019-20 till FY 2023-24. Whether the amount of Rs.25,27,000 is taxable? If Yes under which head? If No, under what section exemption can be claimed?.Please advise..

BY: CA Ravish Thakur

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

While Filling up Form 18 there are two options a) Proprietor/ Partner and B) Sole Practice. What is the exact difference between Proprietorship and sole practice form of practice between the two ? And What Kind Of Function Which Can Performed By CA Practicing As a Proprietorship Can Not Be Performed By CA Practicing As Sole Proprietor And Vise Versa.

BY: CA INDRANEEL BISWAS

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether 87A rebate is allowed for tax on winning from lotteries?

BY: Sivaraman A.R.

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

A person having possession over a land since last 20 years. He is cultivating the land and produce rice crop out of it. He is not owner of the land. Now owner has entered into agreement to sale with a builder to transfer the said land. Builder paid consideration amount of ?60,00,000 to land owner and deducted TDS u/s 194IA. Builder also paid ?20,00,000 to the person holding possession over the land and deducted TDS u/s 194 IA. How Capital Gain will be attracted in this case? Who will get Indexation Benefit? Who will be eligible for exemption u/s 54B? Please advise.

BY: CA Ravish Thakur

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

I am practicing as a sole proprietary firm , but now want to convert it into a partnership in firm . Will it affect the empanelment status.? Which year will be considered as the year of establishment- Year of starting the firm as a sole proprietary firm or the year in which the conversion has taken place?

BY: INDUKALA VISWANATH

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

in case of bonus stripping how and where is this to be shown in itr2

BY: KUSHAL HEGDE

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

in a case of sale of unlisted share of a salaried employee purchased unlisted shares and sold the shares in 3months from date of purchase i)it is a case of short term capital gains on sale of unlisted shares the party to whom the shares was sold has deducted tds as the sale is more than 50 lakhs sec 194(Q) is applicable and shown as sale of goods and it appears as business receipts in the AIS of the salaried employee how is the correction to be made and shown as sale of securities in the ais as the salaried employee is not a dealer in share 2 where in the ITR2 is short term capital gains on sale of unlisted shares to be shown ?

BY: KUSHAL HEGDE

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Sale 80 Lacs Net Profit 4 Lacs Less than 6% and 8 % Whether Tax Audit is required

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

The client submitted application for cancellation of GST registration on 10 Oct 2020 on voluntery basis. No action from the department till 17 Jun 2024. on 18 Jun 2024 the department communicated an order confirming cancellation of registration w.e.f. 10 Oct 2020. In the mean time the client had issued 3 invoices with GST to his customers. Customers availed ITC. The client paid the GST so collected befiore due date. The client also claimed ITC on purchases for the period from 10 Oct 2020 to 18 Jun 2024. All returns were filed till March 2024. What are the consequences for ITC claimed by client and his customers.

BY: CA. LONIKAR SHASHIKANT ACHYUTR

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

One of my clients has demand related to previous years and dept is adjusting TDS receivable against demand. They have filed appeal against the matter and are still recording TDS receivable for previous year under assets. How to treat this from financial reporting perspective? What are recommended/ suggested disclosures or reporting steps for same.

BY: AYUSH AGARWAL

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

During the departmental GST Audit it is observed that in case of export under LUT, the EGM filed date is later than 3 months from the export invoice date. Hence the department is invoking rule 96A and accordingly demanding Interest for the delayed period. Not only that, they are also invoking section 74, ready with rule 96A(1)(a), and demanding for the IGST on export. Is department justified in asking Interest and IGST for delay in filing EGM. Whether for the purpose of Rule 96A, whether EGM date is important or LEO date ( i.e. Let Export Order) date is important. Rule 96A does not say what is "export out of India". Request professional colleague to guide on this. Thanks for your efforts in advance.

BY: Shridhar H

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear Sirs/Madam I had started my practice in own name and did not opt for any proprietorship firm. A client company has duly appointed me by filing ADT-1 for 5 years. Now I have formed and registered a sole proprietorship firm and got a separate FRN. Now my question is, for those cases where my appointment as auditor has been done in individual name, can I issue the audit report on behalf of the firm. ? What I think is that it is better to issue the remaining time period on the individual name only. Once the next renewal ADT-1 if filed, the firm can be appointed. Kindly share your thoughts on the same. Regards Manish

BY: MANISH KUMAR TRIPATHI

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

A PERSON GIVING SPRITUAL BLESSING TO FALLOWERS AND CHARGING FEES FROM THEM AND HE IS ALSO KNOWLEDGE OF VEDIC AND HOLISTIC SCIENCES AND ALSO AN AYURVEDIC DOCTOR BUT HIS MAIN SOURCE OF INCOME FROM BLESSING. PLEASE GUIDE ME WHETHER GST IS APPLICABLE AND WHAT IS THE CHARGEBALE RATE AND IF ANY ADVANCE RULING PLEASE PROVIDE

BY: SHWETA JAIN

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

FY 22-23 - TO 80 lakhs. Profit 10%. Filed ITR4 FY 23-24 - TO 80 lakhs. Profit 10%. Ready to file with full PL and BS in ITR 3. Is Audit 44AB(e) applicable here?

BY: Sivaraman A.R.

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

In case of AOP, yearly maintenance is received from members in cash as and when required. These cash is deposited into AOP bank A/c. and cheques are issued for expenditure. Whether cash received is revenue receipt of AOP

BY: CA ATUL TOSHNIWAL

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

one my client engaged in the business of developing and selling residential land during the year 2019-20 he sold land worth Rs40 Lacs but by virtue of sec 43CA the value came Rs 10500000 the asessee took Rs 10500000 as consideration resorted to Sec 44AD and filed the return taking the profit @ 8% but A.O. mentioning that profit in real state business used to be 20% assessed the income at 15%. without any evidence otherwise ,Is there any case law in support.

BY: Rajesh Chandra Sharma

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

"Agriculture Land In Rural Area" is covered in "Immovable property" for the purpose of Sec 56 (2)(Vii) or not

BY: Rajesh Chandra Sharma

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

I am a proprietor of CA Firm and also a partner in other CA firm, now we want to merge my proprietor firm into my existing Partnership firm. What is the process of merging CA Proprietor firm into existing CA Partnership Firm, which forms we need to file on SSP Portal ?

BY: ARCHANA KUMAWAT

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

"Explanation 1(b) to Rule 42(5) of CGST Rules 2017 - provides that - for the purposes of rule 42 and this rule, it is hereby clarified that the aggregate value of exempt supplies shall exclude the value of services by way of accepting deposits, extending loans or advances in so far as the consideration is represented by way of interest or discount, except in case of a banking company or a financial institution including a non-banking financial company, engaged in supplying services by way of accepting deposits, extending loans or advances." As such Interest Income is to be Excluded for Rule 42 from Value of exempted supply. Does such interest Income is also to be Excluded from Value of Total turnover( in the denominator) , while calculating Common Input tax credit to be reversed.

BY: Prashanth Karanth

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Officer issued ASMT-10 for scrutiny of returns. In addition, he is demanding copies of financial statements, bank statements etc. Whether we are bound to submit these information

BY: CA ATUL TOSHNIWAL

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

We are a private limited company with a land lease from 2019 to 2037. We completed construction on this land in the financial year 2023-24 and began using the property within the same year. *Depreciation Period:* The Companies Act 2013 specifies a 30-year useful life for buildings, with depreciation rates of 9.5% (WDV) and 3.17% (SLM). However, our lease is only 18 years. Accordingly, we should depreciate the building over the balance period .What rate of depreciation should we adopt ? *Change of Depreciation Method:* We currently use the WDV method, which front-loads depreciation. We are considering switching to SLM to better match our business needs by spreading depreciation evenly over the asset's useful life. This change is justified because with SLM, the depreciation amount remains consistent each year. This approach will help manage the later years' burden of repairs, which would otherwise impact the P&L account more significantly under WDV. Is it permissible to switch from WDV to SLM for this leased asset under these circumstances? We seek guidance on ensuring compliance with regulations and aligning our accounting practices with our business needs.

BY: ADRSH HIREMATH

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Partnership firm is taken over by a partner, all assets and liabilities at book value at 31.03.2024 and continued business as proprietor from 1st April 2024. should the financials of firm as on 31.03.2024 reflect this transfer or it will be taken as post financials event? normal financials to be prepared for firm as on 31.03.2024?

BY: CA Shrawan Suthar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

Partnership firm is taken over by a partner, all assets and liabilities at book value at 31.03.2024 and continued business as proprietor from 1st April 2024 SHOULD THIS BE REPORTED IN TAX AUDIT REPORT OR THIS WILL BE A POST FINANCIALS EVENT? IS THIS BE REPORTED IN TAX AUDIT REPORT?

BY: CA Shrawan Suthar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Is UDIN is required for submission of Incorporation documents of Pvt Ltd Company and if yes, in case of resubmission, fresh UDIN is required

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

With effect from A.Y 2024 -25 only 85% of donation given by a 12AA approved charitable organization to similar organization will be considered as “application” of income. I have a 12AA approved Trust who undertake civil repairs at another approved trust and sometimes even provide food and educational materials to their inmates. Will these kind of outflow be treated as donation and only 85% of such expenditure will be considered as application of money or we can take 100% as application.

BY: C P Ethirajan

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Hello Everyone, I have recently got an audit of Petrol Pump . So whether in Karnataka petrol pumps owners have to file monthly VAT and Excise Duty return every month even after GST? They are filing their GST return every month, stating the sales under "Non-GST Supply". Please share some detailed picture of what general monthly and annual compliances for Petrol Pump owners in Karnataka?

BY: ANKIT JAIN

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether a COP holder can do intra day (share) trading ?

BY: E VARALAKSHMI

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Is any affidavit / Notorised document required in new private limited company formation through SPICe in V3 portal

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Good morning, Background: Since Sep 2022, I'm practicing (under my proprietor firm). I'm planning to join as full time partner in another CA Firm (having 3 partners). My questions: Can I become full time partner without closing my existing proprietor firm? Will it be add any advantage to partnership firm in getting Bank /Govt Audits?

BY: DINESH SURENDRA BHALKIKAR

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether Spectra KDK software is satisfactorily working for Income tax TDS and Tax Audit work

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear Sir/Madam, Please note, a manufacturing company run its own bus for transportation of its employees. Since the appointment letter given to employees does not specify about the Transportaion facility, the GST auditor treats this as service given by employer to employee treating it as related party transaction and applying cost+10% valuation rule asking company to pay the GST liability with interest and penalty. Whether the action of the auditor is justified. Please let me know how to go about this.

BY: Shridhar H

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

Under section 50C of the Income Tax Act, if a person sells a capital asset below registration value, he will be liable to pay capital gain tax treating registration value as sale consideration. This rule is subject to certain tolerance. The section also provides that seller can also ask for valuation to be done if he has any genuine reason for selling at lower value. In such situation, he will offer capital gain tax based on actual value received. But I find in Income Tax portal, the ITR utility by default adopts only registration value and not actual sale consideration. Please look into this and revert.

BY: C P Ethirajan

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether Deposits received from the members of a/an Apartment Owners Association/Residential Association (the Association) towards future supplies is taxable at the time of its receipt? Contentions: 1. Deposits received from the members of an Association towards future supplies is taxable u/s. 7(1)(aa). 2. However, the taxability u/s. 7(1)(aa) attracts only if there is any consideration 3. As per the proviso to section 2(31), a deposit given in respect of the supply of goods or services or both shall not be considered as payment made for such supply unless the supplier applies such deposit as consideration for the said supply. As such can one construe/interpret that- • unless the Supplier (the Association) applies (expends) such deposit (towards any supply) there is no payment made for such supply (and hence no consideration) as per section 2(31) • Taxability u/s. 7(1)(aa) arises only in the case of ‘consideration’. In case of such deposits, deposits received in advance partakes the character of consideration only when Supplier (the Association) applies (expends) such deposit (towards any supply to its members) as per the proviso to section 2(31). • Hence the time of supply shifts to the time of actual application of such deposits as against the date of receipt of payment (herein in advance) as envisaged u/s. 13(2)(a). • Hence no GST to be paid at the time of receipt of such Deposits, but only when and if at all the Supplier (the Association) applies (expends) such deposit (towards any supply to its members).

BY: SREEJITH M G

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

one of my client manufacturing Rice which is exempted goods however its by product '"Bran" is taxable at 5% ,while purchasing some capital goods it has to pay freight to GTA,will RCM be applicable.

BY: Rajesh Chandra Sharma

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

CA office from residential society(Thane district): 1. Is it allowed 2. Any permissions required We are not staying in the residential premises. We want to use entire flat for CA Office

BY: samirkumar gokulbhai kasvala

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

ABC CUSTOM BROKER ASSOCIATION. ASSOCIATION IS CHARIRATABLE ENTITY REGISTERED U/S 12AA OF INCOME TAX ACT. WE ARE CHARGING MEMBERSHIP FEES ANNUALY. TRUST IS WORKING FOR ITS MEMBERS FOR EDUCATING, CONDUCTIONG SEMINARS AND ISSUE SOLVING FOR MEMEBERS WORKING AS CHA. FURTHER MAKING VARIOUS REPRESTATION WITH GOVERNMENT AND TAX AUTHORITIES FOR BETTERMENT OF CHA MEMBERS. WHETHER GST APPLICABLE ON MEMBERSHIP FEES AS ANNUAL MEMBERSHIP CROSS 20 LACS? IS THE ACTIVITIES COVERED UNDER CHARITABLE ACTIVITIES AS PER GST ACT? IS THERE ANY OTHER BENEFICIAL PROVISO TO SUCH TRUST/ASSOCIATIONS WITH RESPECT TO GST EXEMPTION?

BY: AHMEDRAZA ANIS SUMIYA

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

While adding bank account on income tax portal, the validation is failed showing message as ‘EE-WS-BVB-ERR-100020’. How to resolve the issue

BY: CA ATUL TOSHNIWAL

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear Experts REG : RECOVERING GST PAID AT HIGHER RATE pl. share your valuable views and guidance Buyer - B was charged GST at 12% by Seller- S by mistake, while later on it is found that actually this product is with NIL rate of tax B paid off invoice and claimed ITC credit and S paid off GST collected to govt, now during GST audit of B - GST officer found ITC credit wrongly availed as there is NIL rate of tax and asked B to pay off GST for availing ineligible ITC credit of purchase of nil rated product and B has paid of the same demanded by govt now B trying to recover wrong charged GST from S, S is not willing to issue credit note, informing that matter is very old of FY 18-19 and they can not get back amount paid to govt under this circumstance can B apply for refund from Govt as he has paid undue tax as neither seller is liable to pay nor buyer is liable to pay any GST on nil rated product under "undue enrichment" to be refunded back to the payer/suffer, here to Buyer B

BY: VIPUL JHAVERI

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Applied for GST cancellation on 26-4-24 wef 31-3-2024 Last GSTR 3B for march filed a couple of days back Also some interest is payable How should I pay Late fee and Interest

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear Forum, I would like to inquire about the tax (gst) implications for a music distributor who publishes albums for musicians and receives music royalties on their behalf from platforms like Spotify, depositing them into their bank account before paying the royalties to the artists. Should these royalties be taxed under GST, or are they exempt? Additionally, who is responsible for paying this tax?

BY: MUHAMMED AMEEN GUNAJE MOIDU HAJI

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

A Firm wants to surrender GST registration wef 31-3-24 It is filing its GSTR 3B on 26 alongwith Taxes payable Can it pay Late fees as well as Interest @18% in this return as well as it does not want to carry return filing in 24-25 Fin Year

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

I was Practising As A Sole Proprietor till 09-Jan-2024. thereafter my firm was merged with another partnership firm from 10-Jan-2024 till now. My Sole Proprietorship was Appointed As Auditor In Some Companies. My Query Is As A Result Of Merger, Do I Need To Resign In Those Companies By Filing Form ADT-3 And Appoint The Partnership Firm As Auditor By Filing Form ADT-1 Or I don't need to file ADT-3, Just informing board of Directors of companies is sufficient. I kindly request your guidance on this matter, as I have sought answers from various sources but have not received a satisfactory response. Is there any notification, guidance anything to support the view.

BY: ROSHAN CHHAGAN PAWAR

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Sir I am Partner with one of the ca firm and want to make LLP or Company with another professional like CS, Advocate, cost accountant for any other legal services. Sir want to know can I do this. And what's impacts in my existing CA firm.

BY: shekhar nema

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Section selected is 10(23c) instead of 12A. Form Application is not yet approved. Is there any way to withdraw application and file new with correct section

BY: CA. CHAVAN TRUPTI GAJANAN

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

What should be rate of TDS on payment made to Google Singapore for Google workspace, Google suite services. Whether TDS will be applicable, if yes under section 195 or subject to equilisation levy

BY: Ankit Jain

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

For nonfiling of return/nonpayment of tax by supplier of goods If SCN is issued to asessee for excess input claim of input Whether interest and penality be imposed if the Excess claim in GST credit ledger is unutilised

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

The Private Limited company is getting lease of land and development cum occupancy right for 30 years from trust. The trust will get building constructed by company (builder) as donation when completed and some fixed rental amount yearly basis for lease. The company (builder) will use such property for rental income for 30 years. How to give treatment of such donation in books of company ? Can we consider it as intangible asset (consideration for occupancy right)? Can we amortize it for 30 years? Please guide. Further, How to treat in books of accounts of trust. ? Thanks in Advance.

BY: CA DHAVAL GHADIYALI

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Form 10 under Rule 17(2) is required to be submitted electronically two months before the due date of return. Can you please guide as to what is the due date for making such eligible investments, i.e. by when the deposit/investment of the money referred to in clause (b) of sub section (2) of Section 11 of the IT Act is to be made.

BY: Nilanjan Kayal

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Can ITRU be filed with nominal tax under New Tax regime for Fin Year 2022-23

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Can anyone help me with finding cricle rates for Hyderabad as per 01 April 2001 for capital gains calculation? #Hyderabad #CircleRates #CA #ICAI #IncomeTax

BY: CA Shrawan Suthar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

“A” owns a site absolutely and the neighbouring site is owned by “B” absolutely. Both “A” and “B” give their sites for joint development to same builder. Under the advice of developer, the two sites are amalgamated so as to get more floor area. My query is whether any capital gain tax is attracted when two sites of “A” & “B” are amalgamated. This is because when sites are amalgamated, “A” gets 50% right in site owned by “B” previously and vice versa. Does it amount to exchange and capital gain tax is payable. Invite experts opinion on this.

BY: C P Ethirajan

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

During early months of GST implementation GST 3B was filled and submitted fror Aug 2018 When it was filed,System neither added Input in the Credit Ledger nor Output tax was deducted Hpwever Return was filed on Portal Assessse added the above unadjusted figs in GSTR 3B for Sep 18 Now a mismatch notice has come from donotreply@gst.gov.in for Aug 2018 and being asked to submit fresh GSTR 3B for Aug 18(they have reset Return) This will require resetting of Sep 18 return also but resetting has been done for Aug 18 only Whethert we will have to visit Department

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Is GST applicable on hostel services provided by educatinoal trust to its students @ 12% when hostel charges are less than Rs. 1,000/- per day per bed ?? Further can we consider imparting of education and hostel charges as composite supply or do we need to consider it as mixed supply ??

BY: VISHAL BABAN PANDIT

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

A CA firm is conducting Concurrent Audit of bank. Also firm is giving few certificate as part of concurrent audit. Firm asked MRL from Bank . However Bank is of opinion that MRL is not required in case of Concurrent Audit. So kindly guide whether CA form should obtain MRL from Bank. Also guide whehtehr is MRL required from Peer Review point of view.

BY: samirkumar gokulbhai kasvala

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether NRI having carried forward Loss under Income from House property adjust the same against Short Term capital gain from sale of House Property

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Fact of the case:- A partnership firm is to be reconstituted where one partner is retiring and one new partner is coming. The firm has some LAND acquired many years ago. At the time of reconstitution neither the land is revalued nor any part of the land is given to the retiring partner. The retiring partner is getiing only the closing capital balance and nothing else. Query- Whether section 45(4) and 9B are applicable in the above situation where no distribution of the LAND. If it is applicable then how the tax on deemed capital

BY: dhanindra kumar surana

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

A prop firm has to pay Interest to a Super senior citizen around 499000- He does not have any other source of income Is Form 15G required to be obtained

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

A CA firm is conducting Concurrent Audit of bank. Also firm is giving few certificate as part of concurrent audit. Firm asked MRL from Bank . However Bank is of opinion that MRL is not required in case of Concurrent Audit. So kindly guide whether CA form should obtain MRL from Bank. Also guide whehtehr is MRL required from Peer Review point of view.

BY: samirkumar gokulbhai kasvala

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Hi, Is separate Business user ID is required for director to get his / her DSC registered in V3 portal of MCA

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Can anybody please highlight on the scope of audit and audit program in case of statutory bank branch audit of RACC (Retail Asset Credit Centre - Centralized Loan Processing Centre) of a nationalized bank. Particularly in case of appraisal, sanctioning and monitoring of advances pertaining to various branches under that RACC.

BY: ALOK NATH SAHA

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

What is the effective date of resignation of Director of the Private Limited Company. Is it the date of notice by the Director or the date on which the resignation is accepted by the Company in its Board Meeting. Can it be the date of Board meeting?

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

I want to receive daily newsletter on my mail

BY: Satyanarayan

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Can We retain our Proprietorship firm and become part of CA Network or LLP

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

A Private Ltd Company has 2 GSTIN in different states. In Delhi, they are dealing in trading of agricultural equipments and is mainly importing the goods. In Haryana, they are dealing in manufacturing of steel products. They have excess ITC balance in Haryana and almost every month, they pay GST liability in Delhi. Now, they want to sell the old obsolete stock from Delhi. Now, my question is whether how they can utilise the excess ITC Balance of Haryana in a legal way to set off the liability in Delhi GSTIN. Is there any legal channel to save the working capital of the company? I f yes, then please let me know. Thanks in advance.

BY: HARSHIT BANSAL

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether CA in Practice can do Intraday trading of equity shares for himself or if required to take permission from Institute.

BY: ASHISH SINGH

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear Forum, A firm is providing health care services and hence the firm did not apply for GST registration as the health care services are exempt from GST. But the firm wants to sell an old medical equipment. Whether the Firm should apply for GST registration? Turnover from the health care services is of Rs.80 Lakh. Thanks in advance.

BY: CA. MADAGALA VENKATA RAMANA

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

SIR, IF EMAIL IS SENT (as provided in covid period) to Previous Auditor, is sufficient compliance or to be sent by Regd AD/Manual only. Please clarify CA. Veerendra Murashillin Hubballi

BY: CA.veerendra.T.Murashillin

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

We have conducted a complete audit of the interim accounts for the period Apr 23 to Dec 23 of a company which is putting it's paper for IPO. Our query is whether the interim audit report to be issued should cover and report on all the matters and clauses of the CARO? If not, which matters should be specifically covered and reported in the interim audit report?

BY: Harpreet Singh Ghai

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

An asessee purchases Yarn, Gets fabricated through a unregistered Fabricator . It itself does not have machinery as such.Is it practically possible to claim GST Refund I?t is not filing Jobwork Returns also

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

A cooperative Society was issued Intimation under Sec 143(1) with demand for Rs 3 Lacs app .for Previous year 2013-14 in 2015 It was not replied/appealed against. Two years back they again received Demand asking for confirmation of demand . Party requested to allow revision of ITR stating It was a clerical error pf entering status o Copperative Society as Cooperative bank Hence Deduction of Sec 80 P was not allowed in intimation order This year again demand notice was issued and grievance was raised again asking for revision i ITr permission Now ITO of the Jurisdiction has asked to file appeal to CIT Appeal ,NFAC

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

How to respond to the ITD intimation seeking clarification with proposed adjustment of standard deduction (proposed disallowance) in Salary Case, wherein the same was arrived automatically from the utility. Assessee is also having Capital Gains, Business income, other income. Return is filed under old regime

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

How to respond to the ITD intimation seeking clarification with proposed adjustment of all Chapter VIA deduction (proposed disallowance) in 44ADA Case, wherein the same was correctly inserted in appropriate colomn in the utility. Return is filed under old regime

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

One person has not linked his pan to aadhar card and due this reason his pan was inoperative. He has not a return filer. So he missed to link. Now he has came into a contract of property of property sale. In that section 194QB has been applicable. The deductor has made the TDS at 1%. But due to inoperative of pan the deductor has received demand notice of 19% amount i.e.(20%-1%). The deductor has deposited some amount against the demand amount. Now we have checked the 26AS of deductee the amount are reflecting in 26 AS. In 26AS part IV column demand payment for 1% amount it is showing as NO and in second row it is showing as demand amount yes. Whether we can claim that 20% deducted amount in our return of income which was due to inoperative of pan. Now the client has linked pan to adhar.

BY: MAHADEO VIRUPAX WALI

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear Collegue, Please clarify the following Query:- A Trust Registered under the Income Tax has filed Form No.10 indicating that the Funds were set apart towards Purchase of Land and Construction of Building for the Trust during the year 2019. However the Trust could not accumulate enough funds to acquire a Land The Five year time limit expires as on 31st March 2024. What is the Remedy available to the Trust? Whether the amount set apart is Taxable as the Trust could not comply with as per Form No.10 filed before the Income Tax Authorities. A.S. Raman

BY: A S RAMAN

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Landowner has registered Development Agreement with Developer for area sharing basis in FY. 2023-24. The landowner and Developer will receive 6 and 8 flats respectively in the newly constructed building. The building is proposed to be completed in FY. 2025-26. If Landowner received booking amount towards some of the flats in newly constructed building. e.g. For 1st flat (Consideration - 35.00 Lacs) - Received Rs. 5.00 Lacs in FY. 2023-24. For 2nd Flat (Consideration - 35.00 Lacs) - Received Rs. 5.00 Lacs in FY. 2024-25. 1) Whether section 145(5A) applicable? 2) In which year, capital gain on land is taxable? - in FY.2023-24, 2024-25 or 2025-26? 3) The amount on which capital gain is taxable?

BY: NAMRATA VIMALCHANDRA KASLAY

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

A cooperative society has received a demand notice demanding Rs 6 Lacs app 3 Tax+3 Interest for Ass Year 2014-15 Pr Year 2013-14 This demand was made around three years back also when it was requested to allow Revised ITR for same year but did not hear from them After this for two years Refund was also issued by Deptt Now they have raised fresh demand and withholding last year refund also Whether revised return for same year can be filed now without deptt permission

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

Whether Gst applicable on borewell Water supply through water Tanker to public and for construction related work??

BY: Ninad Prataprao Shete

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

An Indian citizen working in foreign embassy in India. Whether the salary is taxable. Embassy is not deducting any TDS for the salary paid to its employee.

BY: Shobhit Bansal

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

can we as CA Sign Provisional financial statements for Apr 2023 to Dec 2023. We have verified details and docs.

BY: samirkumar gokulbhai kasvala

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

A cloth manufacturing firm does trading also of certain goods having different HSN. GST on cloth is 5% and on yarn is 12% How to calculate Inverted Turnover for the purpose of refund Whether it should be calculated from turnover only or input value of different HSN's will also be considered assuming input comprising of different HSN is sold

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Goods purchased from MSME .Payment made after 90 days but within same financial year. What will be affect in view of Sec 43 B(h) After Tax auditor pinpoints this whether Interest payment will be payable @three times of bank rate

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

A sister has given gift Rs 10Lacs to his brother through bank whether income derived by brother will be clubbed in sister's income. Further where brother does not earn income but uses this gift to clear his outstanding liability What will be the consequencies

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

If an assessee(mother) wants to transfer her business to her son because of old age,what will be the procedure?tax implications?

BY: Tanisha Sagar Boramanikar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

"A" is suppliers to "B" and A is registered under the MSMED Act, 2006. As per written agreement between A and B, B is required to retain certain amount from bills of A and that retention is 12% of the bills amount without considering any indirect taxes. A has furnished B a Udhyam Registration Certificate. Now B will pay 88% of the bills to A and 12% retain and that retention shall be payable after 24 months from the date of receipt of goods. Shall section 43B(h) apply to such retention upto 12% of the bill amount?

BY: KETAN SHETH

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

A registered person, An architect firm is paying rent to unregistered person for a property being used for his office . Whether he will be covered under reverse charge

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

Myt client has written cheques dated 25.03.2024 to a trade payable falling under the Micro or Small category as defined under the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise Development Act, 2006. As on 31.03.2024, the time period allowed under the said Act, has expired. The said cheque is cleard after 15.04.2024. My client is having (1) current account only, (ii) my client is enjoying credit facilty and that cheque is withing drawing power, or (iii) my client is enjoying credit facilty and his limit got exceeded if auditor counts that chequed dated 25.03.2024. My question is : When is the said cheque dated 25.03.2024 and cleard on or after 15.04.2024 treaed as cleard in the books of account?

BY: KETAN SHETH

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

Dear all, We know that transfer does not take place u/s 2(47) r/w section 53A of TP Act,if the JDA is not registered. What will happen if, there are two persons holding a plot of land jointly and want to construct residential complex.Then how the JDA will be drafted and registered ?? Please throw some light on it.

BY: SUDIP KUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

M/s ABC having banquet hall where they provide their hall for booking to customer and service charges taken on per plate basis however billing is being issued for Hall Rental charges only and GST charged @ 18% and claim ITC etc on input services . Now the GST department team visited at the premises and they asked to M/s ABC to reverse ITC earlier claimed and charged 5% GSTon their Billing (earlier billed also) due to Notification No 20/2019 dated 30 sep 2019 Querry : whether department contention is correct pl. guide with relevant support /ruling

BY: SANDEEP KAPOOR

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

ITC wrongly reversed in Table 4(B)(1) instead of Table 4(B)(2). How to correct the same. Any option

BY: CA. SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

I am a member of ICAI since Jan 2020 and hold COP in my individual name since April 2021. I am not a partner anywhere. My father is a practicing CA and a partner in a CA firm since 2002. Now he wants to resign from that firm and we both want to create our new firm with we both being partners. My query is whether my father's experience of more that 20 years in the past firm be counted in the new firm for bank audits??

BY: ABHINAV AGARWAL

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers