• Registered Users :
  • 159829
  • Current Active Users :
  • 101451

Forum

DID YOU KNOW ?

You can add further comments to your query by clicking on "Add Comment".
This link will appear only, if you are logged-in with your user id and password. The same will appear as
"Querist Comment" on the Forum.

Click here to Post your Query >>
Top 50 Question
Que. Id Date Description
40841
Sep, 22
2020
Service Tax - ( SERVICE TAX ON DOCTOR HEALTH CARE SERVICE )

Whether doctor is liable to service tax for F.Y.2015-16 and afterwards. No / Yes with reason

BY: CA. HEMANG KISHORBHAI AMBANI

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40842
Sep, 22
2020
MISC. - ( DUE DATE OF ESIC/ EPF FOR FEB 20 TO SEP 20 )

PLEASE SHARE WITH ME DUE DATE EXTENSION IN COVID TIME FROM FEB 20 TO SEP 20 FOR ESIC AND EPF LIABILITY

BY: pradeep kumar agrawal

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40843
Sep, 22
2020
GST - ( 080352 )

Whether the CA Firm can claim Input on GST paid on membership fee of its partners? The ICAI asks for the Membership Number of its member only, Can expert member answer why the Firm can not claim the same as input when the Firm has GST registration and partners constitute the firm or ICAI give IGST of partners in the alternative for enabling the claim thereof. Where does the nitty gritty lie?

BY: vijay kumar kalia

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40839
Sep, 21
2020
GST - ( 090631 )

1. a) last year gst paid on advances b) this year invoice issued against that and not shown in gstr 3B 2. advance received for say 10 years and gst duly paid and it is amortised in 10 years in b sheet as income NOW FORM 9 WHERE TO SHOW the above incomes in 1 and 2 TO TALLY WITH SALES IN BALANCE SHEET.

BY: ambeesh marwah

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40840
Sep, 21
2020
GST - ( GST 2A VS GST2B )

while reconciling our books ITC , kindly suggest , either GST2A or 2B to be considered. what is the basic difference between GST 2A and GST 2B

BY: RAM SAMARIA

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40838
Sep, 20
2020
GST - ( REGN CANCELLED SUO-MOTO BUT ASSESSED CONTINUES TO RAISE INVOICE )

An individual assessee was regd under GST. However for 6 months he did not file returns, GST dept issued notice, assessed did not reply and hence regn was cancelled suo-moto. But he continued to raise taxable invoice for 6 more months. Now he is ready to file returns till date of cancellation and then file application for revocation of cancellation. 1. He raised invoices after cancellation. Is it in order? what are the consequences 2. Since he has raised invoices after cancellation, will he be able to file returns after revocation of cancellation (for the period he raised invoices) 3. If the appn for revocation of cancellation is accepted, then what will be date of revocation, will it be be application date or from the date of cancellation

BY: t sankar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40837
Sep, 19
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( INCOME TAX ON NRI )

An individual whose presence in india was slightly above six months during 2019-20 Previous year has gone for higher studies etc to a foreign country.He is earning some income there doing part time job. At the same time a Proprietorship firm is working in his name. Whether his Income from India as well as Foreign country has to be clubbed in 2020-21 Financial year

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40834
Sep, 18
2020
INDIRECT TAXES - ( GST REGISTRATION )

A commissionagent has earned commission in excess of 20 lacs in 2019-20 Whether Limit of Rs 20 Lacs remains unchanged and he will be required to obtain GST registration

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40835
Sep, 18
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( ITR 5 EXCEL UTILITY )

A milk producers cooperative society has to file Income tax return in ITR 5 and entire business income is eligible for deduction under Sec 80 P but we have not been able to validate Schedule B which states deduction under sec 80 P can not be claimed in Schedule P. Whether all members are facing such problem Updated Excel utility also gives the same message.

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40836
Sep, 18
2020
MISC. - ( CURRENCY TRADING )

Dear Sir, We are exporting goods and doing currency trading to manage the risk. For Income Tax, it will be considered as a separate business, but is there any limit from RBI for currency trading to Corporate? Or do we have to take any other approval prior to doing it?

BY: Pujit

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40830
Sep, 17
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( DSC )

How to obtain DSC for a person sitting abroad and not able to return because of Travel restrictions.Whether a simple letter from him to authorize somebody else to file return on his behalf will work

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40831
Sep, 17
2020
GST - ( GST CREDIT ON EXPENSES REIMBURSEMENT )

A Company registered in India incurring testing expenses (on behalf of B) and getting bill from M with GST. In turn A getting reimbursement of expenses incurred on behalf of B in foreign currency. Whether Company A is eligible for taking GST Input credit of bill raised by M on A

BY: CA. BALASUBRAMANIAM P

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40832
Sep, 17
2020
GST - ( REGISTRATION FOR CASUAL TAXABLE PERSON )

Notification 56/2018(central tax) says if casual taxable person makes Inter-state supply of handicraft goods or certain products when made by craftsman predominantly by hands then exemption threshold(rs. 20L) shall be applicable to CTP. Does it mean if casual taxable person doesn't make inter state supply(means make only intra state supply) making of above mentioned goods then CTP have to apply for registration compulsorily as per sec. 24 of cgst act?

BY: GAURAV GUPTA

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40833
Sep, 17
2020
Companies Act, 2013 - ( RECLASSIFICATION OF AUTHORISED SHARE CAPITAL:SH7 REJECTION )

Reclassified existing authorised share capital of rs. 10 lakhs(1 lakhs equity shares of rs. 10 each) to revised share capital of rs.1o lakhs (80k equity shares of rs. 10 each and 20k preference shares of rs. 10 each) and passed special resolution MGT 14 is approved by ROC but SH7 has been sent for resubmission on the ground that " No conversion/re-classification of Equity Shares into Preference Shares or vice. Versa has been permitted under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 (even not provided in Section 61 of the Act), therefore, Pl explain why not e-form may be consideredfor rejection." Please advice Whether we need to file sh7 at all? Read morts/details.asp?mod_id=2807799

BY: Rohit Gupta

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40829
Sep, 16
2020
Income From Salary - ( 019493 )

It is learnt that the Leave encashment received by employees of LIC at the time of retiremnt is also eligible for full exemption u/s.10(10AA) after 01.03.2018 . can anyone support this view with notification ?

BY: nagappan.sm

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40828
Sep, 15
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( INCOME TAX RETURN OF STAMP SELLER )

How to file income tax return of a stamp duty seller who's gross receipts from sale of Stamp is more then 1 cr and it's income is 1.5 percent of Stamp sale further he also deposited the cash in bank account of more then 10 lacs which is further transferred to govt account. Is Gross receipts required to be shown in itr as receipt or only 1.5 percent is income and will be declared in itr.

BY: ANKUSH DUBEY

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

40827
Sep, 13
2020
GST - ( REFUND FOR ZERO RATED SUPPLIES )

our client has applied for their export refunds of oct-18,nov-18 and dec-18 for which department has issued scn informing to allow itc only for itc getting seen in 2A quoting circular 135 on close reading of 135 , it is found that restrictions for refund is due to introduction of rule 36(4) , which itself is introduced for eligible ITC vide notification 43/2019 dt. 09/10/2019, so in our view restricting ITC only as per 2(A) if at all is correct , needs to be applied only for such return period after 9/10/2019 , for eligible ITC , as in case of any earlier period , as 36(4) restrictions were inapplicable ,3B itc are fully eligible for refund and allowing ITC only for amount as seen in 2A for such period seems is a faulty application of law 2.also circular 135 mentions "refund of accumulated ITC shall be restricted to the ITC as per those invoices, the details of which are uploaded by the supplier in FORM GSTR-1 and are reflected in the FORM GSTR-2A of the applicant." it does not specify for which period , so for such invoices if they may not be seen on those month's 2A but it is seen even in earlier or later months 2A , implying genuine credits , such ITC as seen in any 2A stands eligible for refund Expert friends , Kindly share your views and opinions vipul d jhaveri - mubai- vdjmum@gmail.com

BY: VIPUL JHAVERI

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40823
Sep, 11
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( TAX DEDUCTED BY BANK )

A Bank has deducted Tax for Cash Transactions being in excess of Certain Prescribed Limits from a Cooperative Society. Can this be claimed while filing Income Tax returns . Tax deducted is not appearing in 26AS for relevent year

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

40824
Sep, 11
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( JOINT HOME LOAN )

A house is owned by Mrs. X. A home loan has been taken on said property by Mr. and Mrs. X (Co-borrowers). The EMI of the said loan has been paid from Mr. X Bank account. Who is eligible to claim deduction for Principal and Interest under Income Tax? If none of them are eligible, what is the general practice adopted by the professionals and in whose return deduction is claimed?

BY: CA ROHIT GARG

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40825
Sep, 11
2020
AUDIT - ( TAX AUDIT FOR MULTIPLE BUSINESSES )

I have an assessee who is carrying on 2 businesses 1. Photo Development Service - T.O (12 lakhs) 2. Commodity Trading (Futures Intraday, delivery is not there, squared off daily) - T.O (56 Crores) For 2nd business, he incurred 3 lakhs loss and intend to carry forward this speculative loss, hence tax audit is applicable here - Even sum of absolute figures (Profit/loss) per transaction also more than 1 crore, tax audit is inevitable In this case, how to proceed for tax audit. Is it possible to disclose speculative loss and avail presumptive taxation scheme for 1st business or both turnovers needs to be aggregated? For 2nd business what is the Turnover to be disclosed in ITR - Full sale - 56 crore, sum of absolute figures - 2 Crore? Plesae guide me in both tax audit and filling of information in ITR perspective also. Need experts help in proceeding further. Thanks in advance.

BY: UDAY KIRAN

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40826
Sep, 11
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( STAMP VENDOR - TAX AUDIT )

A person is engaged in selling of stamp papers. He procures the stamp papers from haryana government's website and sell to persons after charging his commission. Commission is not fixed by government but he charges it on his own discretion. For the purpose of Tax Audit, should we consider commission amount only or the whole sale proceeds from sale of stamp paper?

BY: CA ROHIT GARG

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40822
Sep, 08
2020
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS - ( HIGHSALE - REG )

Party A in USA making an order on Party B in USA and inturn Party B in USA making order of the material from Party C in India. Party C has manufactured the material and Exporting it to Part B in USA. Material has moved out of Indian port meantime Party A is getting an order for the above material from India hence Party A wants to instruct Party B to do a highsea sale agreement to send the goods back to India to Part D? Is the above transaction possible if so kindly provide documentation required and any other additional compliances?

BY: CA. BALASUBRAMANIAM P

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40821
Sep, 07
2020
MISC. - ( RETIREMENT OF ONE PARTNER IN CA FIRM (FURNISHING OF REQUISITE FORMS) )

A - CA firm having 3 partners, one of the partner retire today. Please advice me which form we need to send to our Institute, further the retiring partner was also in charge of a separate branch. Kindly let me know all the forms which need to be filed with CA Institute and with GST for the closing of that particular branch , since that branch has operated in a separate GSTN No.

BY: pradeep kumar agrawal

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40820
Sep, 06
2020
Companies Act, 2013 - ( PRIVATE COMPANY ACCEPT LOAN FROM SHAREHOLDERS )

Private Limited company can accept loan from Situation 1) Can accept loan from Shareholders? If yes, please provide section 2) Can accept loan from Relative of directors? If yes, please provide section 3) Can accept loan from friends of directors or shareholders? If yes, please provide section 4) Company taken loan from directors but subsequently directors resigned from directorship. Can loan will be treated as deposit?

BY: RAMESH K S

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40817
Sep, 05
2020
GST - ( AVAILABILITY OF GSTR 2A )

CAN ANYBODY THROW SOME LIGHT ON THE DATE OF AVAILABILITY OF GSTR 2A IN GST PORTAL.PLEASE LET ME KNOW THE NOTIFICATION,IF THERE IS ANY.THANK YOU.

BY: SUDIP KUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40818
Sep, 05
2020
MISC. - ( NO OF ARTICLES TO BE REGISTRED UNDER CA )

Howmany No of Articles to be registred under CA who is in contiguous practice of morethan 3 years It means Only after FCA can engaged 2nd Article cleark In my views Smartly revised guidlines by ICAI ?? latest guidlines for no of articles ??

BY: HARSHAD JAYANTIBHAI VAGHELA

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40819
Sep, 05
2020
TDS/TCS - ( TDS ON SALARIES )

For Financial Year 2019-20 , the position of Form 24Q filed are as under . For Quarter 1 and 2 deductor was liable for TDS dedcution and same was paid and filed TDS return . For Quarter3 and 4 Deductor was not liable for TDS decution and hence filed NIL declaration. Now, are submitting request for Form 16 . The message displayed is ‘’no data is available’’ . Also there is message that ‘’ Form 16 will not be available for the PAN(s), which are not mentioned in the Annexure-II of Form 24Q for Quarter (Q4) We have to mention that for Quarter4 deducted was liable for deduction and hence not deducted any TDS. So without TDS challan, TDS return can not filed and consequently Annexure II of Form 24Q also could not filed. So our query is that how to download TDS certificate for Quarter1 and Q2

BY: samirkumar gokulbhai kasvala

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40816
Sep, 04
2020
GST - ( CONTRACT CANTEEN SERVICE )

What is the GST rate on Contract Canteen Service?

BY: NARENDER YARRAGORLA

Total Answers : 4 | View Answers | Post Answers

40814
Sep, 02
2020
GST - ( GST INPUT CREDIT - COMPUTER GENERATED INVOICES )

Hi all, We are receiving Computer generated Invoices from BSNL and GST input credit taken based such invoices and no hard copy of Invoices with signature available. Is Computer generated Invoices are a valid for availing GST Input credit

BY: CA. BALASUBRAMANIAM P

Total Answers : 4 | View Answers | Post Answers

40815
Sep, 02
2020
GST - ( GST AUDIT U/R 80(3) OF CGST RULES,2017 )

WHAT IS THE PRESENT LIMIT FOR NOT GETTING AUDITED ACCOUNTS U/R 80(3).IN FY 2017-18 IT WAS RS 2 CRORES.PLEASE REFER NOTIFICATION NO IF THERE IS ANY CHANGE.

BY: SUDIP KUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40811
Sep, 01
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( OPTING FOR PRESUMPTIVE TAXATION )

A person is getting his accounts audited under Tax Audit for Financial yr 2017-18 and 2018-19. Can he choose to opt for Presumptive Taxation this Financial year 2019-20 .

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40812
Sep, 01
2020
GST - ( INPUT CREDIT BASED ON COPY INVOICE )

Whether we can avail the GST Input Credit based on Copy Invoice.

BY: CA. BALASUBRAMANIAM P

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40813
Sep, 01
2020
GST - ( IS HSN CODE IS MANDATORY ON INVOICES )

Whether HSN Code needs to be mandatory mentioned in the Invoices for availing Input Credit.

BY: CA. BALASUBRAMANIAM P

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

40810
Aug, 31
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( ITR FORM 4 )

Hi sir/madam I have a question regarding of ITR form to be submitted of my client, he is having Commission income under 194D and he dont maintain books of account of Retail business (44AD) Can i file ITR 4 Or need to fill ITR 3 ?

BY: RAGHURAMIREDDY

Total Answers : 5 | View Answers | Post Answers

40807
Aug, 29
2020
GST - ( E COMMERCE OPERATOR )

One person wants to sale products through amazon.He will purchase goods from registered suppliers. Will he be treated as e-commerce operator ?? It is pertinent to mention that he has already taken registration as e-commerce operator few days ago.Now amazon people say that TCS will be deducted by them not by him ?? How should he go about it ?? Will he amend or cancel his registration as ecommerce operator ??

BY: SUDIP KUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY

Total Answers : 7 | View Answers | Post Answers

40808
Aug, 29
2020
Companies Act, 2013 - ( RESIGNATION OF DIRECTOR )

Can a Director resign from Directorship of a Company pending filing of DIR-ACTIVE and DIR KYC

BY: SURAJ KUMAR CHOUDHARY

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

40809
Aug, 29
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( PAN APPLICATION BY A RELIGIOUS BODY )

A Gurdwara set up a few years back want to get PAN (This is required by Bank) What documents will be required for that Will it be Trust deed or any thing else.

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

40804
Aug, 28
2020
GST - ( GSTR1 AMENDMENT )

A taxpayer was Normal scheme dealer till 31.03.2020 . From 01.04.2020, he has opted for composition scheme dealer. For FY 2019-20 , two sales invoices was not reported. Now he wants to report these 2 transactions of FY 2019-20 so that he can pay proper taxes and customer can get credit . Our query is that how to report these transactions. From FY 2020-21 , he is into composition scheme so not eligible to file GSTR1 .

BY: samirkumar gokulbhai kasvala

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40805
Aug, 28
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( CAPITAL GAIN )

An individual enters in to agreement with developer for purchase of an apartment in 2018, and regularly pays the instalment dues to developer in 2020 when the apartment in ready for delivery he executes into tripartite sale deed by which the apartments is registered in the name of third party. This results in substantial gain for the first agreement holder which can be treated as Long term capital gain. My question for purpose of re-investments, is he to comply with provision of section 54 or 54F.

BY: Ethirajan

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40806
Aug, 28
2020
GST - ( GST APPLICABILITY )

“A”, real estate company enters into agreement with land owner for purchase of land for Rs.50L and pays advance of say 30 Lacs. Shortly the company finds a buyer for 60 lacs. Sale deed is directly executed by the land owner to actual buyer with the with 'A' as consenting party for Rs. 60Lacs. The buyer pays 20Lacs to land owner and 40 lacs to the real estate company. My queries are 1. Is company liable for GST since what is transferred is not land per se, but only right in the land 2. If the company is liable for GST, is it on 60 lacs or on 10 lacs, being the margin money

BY: Ethirajan

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40802
Aug, 27
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( USE OF DSC BY AUTHORISED REPRESENTIVE )

An illiterate person is not able to get DSC.Can he authorise some body else to use his DSC for his Prop firm's Income tax return by giving authorisation letter

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 2 | View Answers | Post Answers

40803
Aug, 27
2020
GST - ( SALE OF OLD TRUCK (ISSUE OF CHARGING OF GST) )

X A business man engaged in trading purchased a Truck of Rs 20 L + GST 28% 5.60 = 25.60 in FY 2019-20. The GSt of Rs 5.60 was taken as input in the FY 2019-20. In CY 2020-21 now he wants to sale the truck for Rs 17 Lacs after deducting dep. My query is whether he will have to charge GST on sale price of truck of Rs 17.00 L + GST 28%. Or Input taken in FY 2019-20 ought to be reversed considering 1 year of usage of machinery in the business. Which option he will have to consider here.

BY: pradeep kumar agrawal

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40800
Aug, 26
2020
GST - ( GST )

A person raised 3 invoices to service receiver in F Y 2017 2018 but due to some mistake not uploaded right credit against each invoice. Now the receiver raised a debit note along with tax & Interest. Due to the fact that he is an Important customer, supplier can not bought him to his knees. Now the question is: 1. can the supplier get the GST refund which he has paid to the department against these invoices since the receiver has raised a debit note, reversed the credit and not paid for the Invoices? Thanks & Regards

BY: SK

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40801
Aug, 26
2020
GST - ( GSTR9 )

While preparing GSTR9 for the FY 2018-19, where to disclose the turnover relating to FY 2017-18 reported in the FY 2018-19.

BY: CA. MALLIKARJUNA RAO SIKHAKOLL

Total Answers : 3 | View Answers | Post Answers

40796
Aug, 25
2020
INDIRECT TAXES - ( REFUND APPLICATION RFD01A )

While filling Sales details in Excel Utility B2C figure is to be filled alongwth Bill wise sales details of Registered customers B2C Sales includes IGST as well as CGST/SGST but Error message comes "Either tax should be IGSTor CGST/SGST Even if we bifurcate into two figures JSON file is not validated after uploading. Can any body suggest solution Thanks in advance Ca Mahesh Aneja

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40797
Aug, 25
2020
INDIRECT TAXES - ( REFUND APPLICATION RFD01A )

While filling Sales details in Excel Utility B2C figure is to be filled alongwth Bill wise sales details of Registered customers B2C Sales includes IGST as well as CGST/SGST but Error message comes "Either tax should be IGSTor CGST/SGST Even if we bifurcate into two figures JSON file is not validated after uploading. Can any body suggest solution Thanks in advance Ca Mahesh Aneja

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40798
Aug, 25
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( 078994 )

An Individual is Govt. Employee. He received Medical Reimbursement from his Employer for Medical Treatment of his Son. Whether its Taxable in the hands of the Individual.

BY: AJAY JAIN

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40799
Aug, 25
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( 078994 )

An Individual Doctor, pays Life Insurance Premium of his Staff. Whether it will be eligible Business expenditure for him.

BY: AJAY JAIN

Total Answers : 0 | View Answers | Post Answers

40794
Aug, 24
2020
DIRECT TAXES - ( TAX AUDIT FOR A COOPERATIVE SOCIETY )

A cooperative Society having turnover less tha Rs 1 crore dealing in Milk,Fertilizers,Karyana Goods has not been allotted to any Chartered Accountant for Tax audit by Department of Cooperation. Its Turnover is slightly less than 1 Crore and Net profit as per Balance Sheet is less than 8% of Turnover which becomes Nil after availing deuction under Sec 80 P Whether Tax Audit will apply to this Society

BY: Mahesh Kumar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers

40795
Aug, 24
2020
Profits & Gains of Business & Profession - ( 44AD )

Financial year 2018-19 TO less than Rs. 1C. assessee did not avail 44D, but filed under normal accounts I know that for the next 5 years he cannot avail 44AD. But for 2019-20, he avails 44AD and files return. What will happen if this return is not accepted.

BY: t sankar

Total Answers : 1 | View Answers | Post Answers